Skip to content
Aspen HR
  • About
    • Why Aspen
    • Our Team
    • Careers
  • Solutions
    • White Glove HR
    • Employee Benefits
    • Payroll & HRIS
    • Expanding to the U.S.
    • ESG
  • Industries
    • Case Studies
    • PEO for Technology Companies
    • PEO for Alternative Investment Firms
    • PEO for Life Sciences Companies
  • Locations
    • Locations Nationwide
    • PEO in California
    • PEO in Texas
  • Resources
    • Client Login
    • Marketplace
    • Insight
    • Benefits Resources
  • Contact Sales

The Qualities of Great Managers and How to Develop Them

By aspenadminAugust 25, 2022May 25, 2023Employee Well-Being
Great Managers and How to Develop Them
Share this article

Guest blog provided by Mineral, authored by Lisa DeShantz-Cook

  • Great bosses don’t happen by accident. They need the right kind of training and insights to develop.
  • Bad management practices are contagious, but good ones can be also.
  • Managing managers is its own kind of leadership, but we’ve got tips to help.

Think about your favorite manager. Now think about what made them your favorite. Try to think about, for you, what make up the qualities of great managers. Was it the success you earned while working with them? Your employer may have evaluated them based on metrics like team productivity or turnover rates. Great managers are usually good at leading productive, low-turnover teams, but those aren’t the things their employees remember.

So what about them left such an indelible mark on you? Perhaps this manager was easily approachable and worthy of your trust. Maybe they effectively led your team through a major change and had your back the whole way. Perhaps they were always laser-focused on developing their team—on developing you.

In our view, the success of a manager is defined by the success of the people they lead. We rate a manager’s performance based largely on how their team is doing. That’s what helps define the qualities of great managers.

Bad Management Practices Are Rampant, But That Can Change

Unfortunately, the terrible manager remains a popular character in our collective consciousness—and for good reason. There’s no shortage of managers unwisely promoted into the role or given insufficient training to manage people well.

Managing HR and Compliance Issues

You’ve got the micromanager, the bully, the leader who plays favorites, and the boss who emails subordinates in the middle of the night only to not be available for clarification or responses during the workday. You’ve likely met or heard about the manager who frequently blows off meetings, neglects to give needed details on a project, or takes credit for the work of others. Horror stories abound in review sites, online communities, and conversations across the land.

With bad management practices so rampant, it’s easy for people to forget that there are lots of managers who do their job well. Many do it exceptionally well. That’s why we want to look at the characteristics of the best managers and what businesses can do to hire, promote, and develop these leaders.

Qualities of Great Managers

The best managers work hard to improve the work lives of their team members. A big part of that is setting and communicating clear expectations. Good managers focus on performance, so their people get better at what they do. This includes empowering employees to identify development areas that matter the most to them. Another big part is facilitating cooperation so that their reports work better together and better with other teams. The best managers also recognize and advocate for their people. They listen carefully to know what their people need to be successful, and they aim to deliver it.

These managers are empathetic, understanding, and supportive. They listen to their people and have a keen understanding of what motivates and inspires them. They’re available to troubleshoot problems, brainstorm ideas, and provide guidance on projects. They communicate effectively and correct mistakes in ways that build people up rather than tear them down. These managers teach what they know and always seek to learn. They have an eye for equity.

Developing the Qualities of Great Managers

If your managers—or the people you intend to promote into management—don’t have all of these qualities, don’t worry. These traits and behaviors can be taught and nurtured. Managers also need to be managed. Here are some ways you can build more effective managers and nurture the traits that make managers great.

1. Train New Managers After You’ve Promoted Them

When you promote a stellar employee into a managerial role, you also must give them the tools to successfully manage people. They may feel ready to lead a team, but it’s up to the employer to be certain they know the responsibilities involved, and how your organization wants them to execute those responsibilities. Also consider managers that are building a new team. Do they have the resources to successfully interview candidates? Perform tasks in your applicant tracking software? Communicate with HR or recruiting about the process? Your newer or less experienced leaders may have ideas about the way they want to manage based on their experience as employees—but that’s not enough.

To build truly successful managers, leadership may need to go back to the basics and provide not only base-level training, but clear avenues for answers, guidance, and support. Should new managers go to their own managers first or to HR with questions or problems? These are things that should be spelled out and communicated, even if you think they might be obvious or rudimentary.

It also doesn’t hurt to prepare new managers for the role before you hire or promote them into it. Talk with them about what the job will be like, especially if they haven’t managed before. Go over what’s needed and what’s nice to have. Be open about the struggles and the stress the new manager can expect to experience. Make sure they have the desire to manage.

2. Practice Presence

Most managers don’t want to or have the time to micromanage. They hope their reports have the skills and knowledge to do the job they were hired to do, so they take a hands-off approach and let their reports get to it. Or they’re too busy with their own projects to do anything more than basic managerial duties. But that’s a sure way to see projects or tasks go off-track, especially if managers don’t make themselves available for troubleshooting, or provide clarity on instructions.

Remind your managers to treat silence from their reports as an opportunity to check in, offer an ear, problem solve, or simply cheerlead. Check-ins don’t have to be formal, overwhelming, or take more time than necessary. Software programs that allow employees to note what they’re working on or bring up obstacles and share these with their manager can be a great tool and don’t have to take anyone more than a few minutes at a time. Less formal but still as productive, a scheduled check-in call (at an agreed-upon frequency) gives managers insight into projects and helps employees feel heard and celebrated.

3. Guide the Guiders

Good managers don’t necessarily have all the answers—but they know where to get them. Company leadership should aim to provide managers at all levels with the resources and training they need to do their best for their reports. Do your people leaders have access to mentors either inside the company or with partners or resource groups, and do you encourage these relationships? Mentorship programs, “day-in-the-life-of” presentations, or even informal programs that connect managers from different departments can provide managers with inspiration and support.

Newer managers might not know immediately how to handle a situation where an employee has a health crisis or family issue that suddenly takes them away from work. Do your managers know where to turn? Is there an online repository for information and guidance for situations managers may be presented with (and do all managers know about it)? Or would you rather they immediately bring the issue to HR?

Programs can be robust, such as mandatory manager trainings scheduled throughout the year, or as simple as setting up an internal messaging process (e.g., Slack, Skype, text messaging) or smaller interdepartmental groups of managers that can provide informal support to one another. Whether your company has the budget for a formal training program or not, connections can and should be made to support managers.

If you’re not sure where your managers could use guidance or development, ask them. They’re more likely to be engaged in their development if they have a say in what they’re learning. Lifelong learning is another of the qualities of great managers.

4. Promote Teamwork Among Managers

Are your managers operating as a team? Each of your managers has a distinct personality and approach to management that affects their leadership style. One may be highly self-driven while another needs deadlines to motivate action. Another may focus on building their team’s strengths, another on correcting their team’s weaknesses. One may communicate a lot, another only a little.

These differences can work, but they can also cause confusion and inequality, whether real or imagined. For instance, employees who report to or work with more than one manager may not know what is expected of them. Or they may find themselves overworked if managers don’t coordinate workloads. Cross-team efforts may be delayed or even ruined due to misunderstandings or failures to communicate. The company may be guided by several conflicting personalities instead of a single, unified company culture. In extreme cases, inconsistent management practices may lead to discrimination claims.

To bring managers together, you need something to unite them around. This is your company culture—the personality of the organization, its mission and values, working environment, policies, and practices. Ensure your managers are following consistent management practices, making decisions aligned with the values of the company, and regularly communicating with one another about their needs, obstacles, and workforce changes.

Our Client Retention

Neither good managers nor bad managers exist in a vacuum. They either have the support or the inattention of company leadership—the latter to dangerous consequences. A culture of poor management can lead to employee dissatisfaction, burnout, and increased turnover, all of which can be costly. An investment in selecting with intention and building the qualities of great managers is not just an investment in them, but an investment in the company.

Author: Lisa DeShantz-Cook

Lisa DeShantz-Cook, PHR, is a career copy editor and writer and has been editing HR and employment law copy for almost 20 years. She occasionally writes on HR topics, has been published in Quartz, and was recently interviewed for an article published in Business Insider.


Share this article
HRhuman resourcesPEOpeople

Post navigation

Making the Most of Job Interviews
Workplace Investigations: A Framework for Success

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Industry News

HUB Mental Health Article

Employers Supporting Mental Health in the Workplace

by HUB

Read Article

Employee Mental Health PDF

6 Best Practices for Addressing Employee Mental Health Needs

by HUB

Download

Entrepreneurship Boom

The economy's lasting start-up boom

Axios

Read Article

New Retirement Rules 2023; 401k Changes in 2023

New Retirement Rules: How Your IRA and 401(k) Are Changing in 2023 and Beyond

CNET

Read Article

Napeo Logo

7 NAPEO Members Recognized on Inc. Magazine's List of 5000 Fastest Growing Businesses

Yahoo Finance

Read Article

AspenHR in Inc 5000

AspenHR Named #3 in PEO and Recognized for 580% Growth

Inc. 5000 List

View on LinkedIn

Why Human Resource Management

What Every Business Owner Needs to Know About Human Resource Management

on Inc.

Read Article

COVID Workplace

COVID-19 Did a Number on the Workforce – and the Workplace

on US News

Read Article

What Employees Want at a Job

The Top 6 Things Employees Want in Their Next Job

on Gallup

Read Article

USA Today HR Article

How do I address salary discrepancies? Ask HR

on USA Today

Read Article

InSync PEO Podcast

InSync PEO Podcast: AspenHR CEO Mark Sinatra on the Second Time Around

by Kirk Flagg

Read Article

VS Helping Startups

ESG and HR: How Investment Funds Can Comply

by AspenHR

Download

VS Helping Startups

How VCs Can Help Startups Set (and Meet) ESG Goals

on HBR

Read Article

ESG

ESG Funds Managing $1 Trillion Are Stripped of Sustainable Tag by Morningstar

on Bloomberg

Read Article

HR Primer Managers Guide

HR Primer for Emerging Managers

by AspenHR

Download Now



What We Offer

White Glove HR Payroll and HRIS Employee Benefits FAQ

About Us

Why Aspen Leadership Team Contact Us Careers

Resources

Blog Client Tools Benefits Resources Marketplace

© 2023 Aspen HR, All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy

Website Services by De Lu Studios

LI Twitter
We’ve updated our privacy policy to bring you a more personalized Aspen HR experience.
Click "accept" or review changes here.
Accept
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
CookieDurationDescription
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT

FREE RESOURCE

10 Critical Questions to Ask Your PEO

Choosing the right professional employer organization (PEO) is hard… There are many PEOs out there and it can be a challenge to truly understand the differences among them to pinpoint the right PEO for you.

These 10 questions are critical in helping you better identify the right PEO for you and your company to partner with.

Loading

FREE RESOURCE

10 Critical Questions to Ask Your PEO

Choosing the right professional employer organization (PEO) is hard… There are many PEOs out there and it can be a challenge to truly understand the differences among them to pinpoint the right PEO for you.

These 10 questions are critical in helping you better identify the right PEO for you and your company to partner with.

Loading

Contact Sales

Fill out the form below and one of our sales team members will be in touch shortly.

Loading

About
May McClelland

Managing Director of Operations

May brings over 21 years of PEO experience to Aspen HR. She began in the industry as a payroll professional and held a variety of positions throughout several PEOs as a new client Implementation Specialist, Mid-Market Payroll & Implementation Manager, and most recently, Director of Implementation at Engage PEO. She joined at start-up of Engage in 2012 to lead and grow the implementation department, directly contributing to the quick growth of the company to over 40,000 worksite employees in 10 years.

May graduated from Florida Atlantic University with a BS in Psychobiology, has held a Certified Payroll Professional designation since 2009, and is an American Payroll Association member.

Connect On LinkedIn

FREE RESOURCE

Why ESG Is Important to Financial Services Companies

In this PDF presentation created by RadiantESG and AspenHR, you will learn about:

  • The economic power of ESG
  • Identifying risks and opportunities
  • The intersection of ESG and HR
  • 4 tactical ways to implement ESG at your company
Loading

Get White-Glove HR

Aspen enables your company to outperform through the power of white-glove HR. Fill out the form below to get a quote!

Loading

About
Mark Sinatra

CEO at AspenHR

Mark Sinatra is the CEO of Aspen HR where he leads the strategic direction and growth of the company. Prior to Aspen HR, Mark was CEO of Staff One HR where he led the company through a period of substantial growth highlighted by achieving the Inc. 5000 list of fastest-growing companies for four years in a row, and сulminating in Staff One HR’s sale to its largest privately-held competitor, Oasis Outsourcing, in December 2017. Mark oversaw the Western half of the country for Oasis Outsourcing until its sale to Paychex for $1.3bn in December 2018. Prior to his leadership experience in the HR industry, Mark worked as a consultant and investment banker.

Actively involved in his community and industry, Mark has served as a Board director for NAPEO and ESAC and two non-profit organizations. He is also an active member of Young Presidents’ Association.

Mark is an MBA graduate of the Wharton School of Business, and holds a BA in Economics from Fordham University. He has earned the SHRM-CP designation, is a Certified Predictive Index analyst, and is a graduate of the Stagen Integral Leadership Academy.

Connect On LinkedIn

About
Jenny Souksavath

Co-Founder, COO

Jenny serves as the COO and is a Co-Founder of Aspen. Prior to joining Aspen, Jenny was Vice President at Ambrose, now known as TriNet Financial Services. Jenny co-led the Bay Area market development for TriNet’s PEO product that specifically focused on the alternative investment industry.

Jenny was previously in KPMG’s asset management group that provided audit, tax, and consulting services for numerous alternative investment firms.

Jenny earned her BS in Business Administration with concentration in Accounting from San Francisco State University College of Business. She currently serves as Co-Chair for Help For Children’s West Coast Executive Committee, a global foundation, supported by the alternative asset management industry. Jenny also co-founded the Pacific Alternative Investment Group in February of 2016.

Connect On LinkedIn

About
Jeff Welton, CPA

Chief Financial Officer

Jeff serves as CFO for AspenHR where he is responsible for overseeing the finance, treasury, and risk & compliance teams. Jeff joined AspenHR in 2018 and brings over 12 years of experience serving and consulting with clients across the asset management and professional services industry.

Before joining Aspen, Jeff spent his first nine years in KPMG’s financial services group and later joined Standish Management as Vice President of Finance. Jeff earned his BS in Accounting from the University of Connecticut and is a Certified Public Accountant and member of the AICPA.

About
Jeanine Schottler

SPHR-CA, SHRM-SCP
Managing Director, HR

Jeanine Schottler is the Managing Director of HR and Client Services for Aspen. Jeanine brings over 20 years of experience, serving in both corporate HR and outsourced capacities.

Before joining Aspen, Jeanine served as the Director of HR Services at Oasis Outsourcing where her teams were responsible for delivering HR services to over 5,000 client organizations and 250,000 worksite employees. During her tenure, Jeanine gained experience in acquisition integration and scaling service operations. She holds a Masters in Organizational Performance and Change from Colorado State University and has earned SHRM-SCP, SPHR, and PHRca designations.

Connect On LinkedIn

About
Rowena Baginski

AspenHR Board Director

Rowena manages all aspects of operations for the firm including, HR, benefits, IT infrastructure and recruiting. For our clients, Rowena specializes in designing and implementing corporate insurance and employee benefits programs. Prior to Standish, she was the Operations Manager at Walden Venture Capital. Earlier in her career Rowena was an analyst in the health insurance industry.

Rowena earned a BA in Economics from the University of California at Berkeley.

Connect On LinkedIn

About
Robert Raynard, CPA

AspenHR Board Director

Bob is the Chief Executive Officer of Standish and Chair of the Board. Before founding Standish in 2006, Bob was the Chief Financial and Administrative Officer of Walden Venture Capital. Prior to Walden, Bob was the CFO at Robertson Stephens Asset Management and a Senior Manager at PricewaterhouseCoopers. At PwC Bob led the Bay Area Private Funds Group in providing audit, tax, and consulting services to venture, private equity, and fund-of-funds. Bob started his career at Ernst and Young in Boston and has been working in the investment management industry since 1993.

Bob earned an MBA from Boston University and a BA from the School of International Service at The American University. Bob is a Certified Public Accountant (inactive) and member of the AICPA and California Society of CPAs.

About
Midge Seltzer

AspenHR Board Director

Midge is a recognized leader with extensive experience in the Professional Employer Organization (PEO) and Human Capital Management (HCM) industries. After a successful career practicing law, she started in the PEO industry in 1999. As a C-suite executive, Midge was instrumental in founding, operating and growing two successful PEOs, Engage PEO and Modern Business Associates.

Midge also served in a number of leadership roles of distinction within the PEO community. On the national level, she is a past Chair of the National Association of Professional Employer Organizations (NAPEO) and long-time board member; she chaired NAPEO’s Federal Government Affairs Committee (FGAC), NAPEO’s Political Action Committee (PAC) and NAPEO’s Legal Advisory Council. Regionally, Midge was appointed to Florida’s Department of Business and Professional Regulation’s Board of Employee Leasing Companies, where she also served as Chairperson; and Midge is a former Vice President of the Florida Association of Professional Employer Organizations (“FAPEO”).

In 2019, Midge was the proud recipient of the PEO industry’s highest honor, the Michaeline A. Doyle Award, for her leadership and contributions to the industry.

A frequent author and speaker, Midge began her career practicing international law as a litigator and transactional attorney in Miami, Florida; she has substantial experience in corporate, regulatory, mergers and acquisitions, and labor and employment law.